Translated from Hebrew article originally published here
by Dr. Rachel Warzburger, Van Leer Institute, Jerusalem
This article was written in response to a screening of Sabbath Queen at the Van Leer Institute in Jerusalem in August 2025, followed by a conversation led by the author, along with Rabbi Nerya Knafo
In the opening scene of the film Sabbath Queen, directed by Sandi Dubowski, Rabbi Amichai Lau-Lavie sits in a spacious room prepared for what looks like a wedding ceremony, speaking with two grooms-to-be, both dressed as Zen monks. One of them, we later learn, is Jewish; the other is not. Aware of the unusual situation, Lau-Lavie looks straight at the camera and says quietly, in English: “I broke the law. My choice… represents a betrayal.”
The documentary follows Lau-Lavie’s complex and multifaceted life over two decades: an Israeli, queer, performance artist who brought to life the drag persona of Rebbetzin Hadassah Gross; the founder of Lab/Shul, a pop-up, experimental Jewish community in New York; and a rabbi ordained by the Conservative movement. But Lau-Lavie is not only these things—he is also heir to a rabbinic dynasty of 39 generations. He is the cousin of Israel’s current Ashkenazi Chief Rabbi, David Lau; the nephew of former Chief Rabbi Yisrael Meir Lau; and the brother of Rabbi Benny Lau, who led a prominent religious-Zionist community in Jerusalem. This illustrious lineage—shaped by the survival story of his father and uncle, the only members of their family to emerge alive from Nazi concentration camps—is for Lau-Lavie both an honor and a heavy burden.
Throughout the film we witness the tension he feels as he looks back on his choices, balancing his family’s rabbinic tradition with his own path. Lau-Lavie is not a “former religious” Jew in the typical sense (if such a category even exists)—not someone who simply discarded the weight of religious heritage to live a secular life. For him, freedom does not mean abandoning Jewish tradition, but rather the opposite: seeking to return to it, to re-approach it. Yet this return requires reshaping Judaism in bold and subversive ways, especially when measured against the conservative norms of Israeli Orthodoxy.
From Avant-Garde to the Rabbinate
The film documents Lau-Lavie’s intertwining personal and professional journeys after his move to the United States: first as an openly gay avant-garde artist, and later as a spiritual teacher and leader of an experimental community of artists. Joining the Radical Faeries, a queer neo-pagan spiritual movement, he begins performing in drag as Rebbetzin Hadassah Gross—the Jewish counterpart to Dame Edna, if you like. Soon after, he develops Storahtelling, a performance-ritual blending theatrical storytelling with the Torah reading ritual, which grows into Lab/Shul, the community he now leads. Lab/Shul describes itself as “an experimental, artist-driven, God-optional, everybody-friendly community for sacred Jewish gatherings.”
But Lau-Lavie goes further: he enrolls at the Jewish Theological Seminary and receives rabbinic ordination. This decision surprises, even unsettles, his friends and collaborators, who cannot understand why an artist of transgression would “return” to the institutional frameworks of organized Judaism.
This tension is exactly what Lau-Lavie embodies: between institutional and non-institutional Judaism; between a tradition that sees itself as a direct continuation of the past and one that seeks to reshape and renew that past. Like other figures in the Jewish Renewal movement in North America and Israel, he strives to adapt Judaism to the spirit and values of the present—even at the cost of upsetting or breaking away from mainstream Judaism. Indeed, since the 1970s, movements such as the Havurah and Jewish Renewal have pioneered alternative, egalitarian, progressive, spiritually vibrant approaches to Judaism outside of institutional frameworks. Their rituals often creatively reimagine traditional practice, sometimes borrowing from non-Jewish sources like meditation, shamanism, or Sufism. In this vein, Lau-Lavie’s drag persona, Lab/Shul’s experimental rituals, and his decision to officiate a wedding for two men—one not Jewish—push the boundaries of Jewish tradition, even for liberal Jewish communities in North America.
Jewish Renewal and the Boundaries of Tradition
Here it is worth pausing on the term Jewish Renewal. Unlike “reform” or “change,” which imply an outside effort to create something new, renewal is a slower, more reflexive process—change from within, almost as if it grew organically. The aim is to revive ancient tradition in a way that speaks to the spiritual needs of the present. This renewal involves presenting the reimagined Judaism as authentic, and therefore legitimate. But it also raises the constant question: how far can norms be stretched before Judaism ceases to be recognizable as Judaism? Can a prayer service be led by a nonbinary rabbi? Can shamanic ritual be integrated into Jewish prayer? Can a rabbi officiate at an interfaith gay wedding?
The answers vary widely depending on context. For liberal American Jews of the early 21st century, gender equality and same-sex marriage are non-issues. But in Orthodox and conservative Israeli society, they remain deeply contentious. Similarly, borrowing non-Jewish rituals like Buddhist meditation or shamanic practices would not be acceptable in mainstream Reform or Conservative synagogues in the U.S.—and open anti-Israel or anti-Zionist stances are equally controversial.
These dilemmas appear vividly in the film: Lau-Lavie praying with Women of the Wall, demonstrating against the Gaza war and facing harsh criticism, or wrestling with the decision to officiate the interfaith gay wedding that opens the film. His ordination by the Conservative movement places him squarely within an institution that has formally ruled against such marriages. By proceeding anyway, he knowingly placed himself outside its bounds.
Yet beyond Lau-Lavie’s personal dilemma lies the broader question of Judaism’s survival in the 21st century. Will preserving traditional frameworks ensure its continuity? Or will the courage to reimagine the sacred breathe new life into it—making Judaism meaningful for this generation and those to come?


